“No-logs” is the headline promise on almost every VPN website, but it is also one of the hardest claims to check. A no-logs VPN says it keeps no record of what you do while you are connected — yet nothing stops any provider from simply printing those words on a sales page. This guide explains what a genuine no-logs policy covers, how independent audits, diskless servers and real court cases turn the claim into evidence, and the exact checks you can run before you trust a provider with your traffic.
What a no-logs VPN actually means
A VPN (virtual private network) routes your internet traffic through an encrypted tunnel to a server run by the provider, hiding your real IP address and what you do from your internet provider. If you are new to the idea, our plain-English guide to how a VPN works covers the basics. Because all of your traffic passes through that server, the provider is in a position to record it — and “logs” are simply the records a server can keep.
There are two broad kinds of logs, and a true no-logs (sometimes called “zero-logs”) VPN avoids both in any form that could be traced back to you:
- Activity or usage logs: the websites you visit, DNS lookups, apps you use and files you download. This is the sensitive, identity-revealing data most people worry about.
- Connection or metadata logs: your real IP address, the VPN IP you were assigned, session timestamps, how long you connected and how much data you moved. On its own this can still be enough to link a session to a person.
Most reputable providers keep a small amount of non-identifying operational data to run the service (see the limitations below). The question that matters is whether they keep anything that could tie a specific online action to you.
Why the label is easy to claim and hard to prove
No law requires a “no-logs” statement to be accurate, and the words cost nothing to add to a website. Some providers have been caught retaining data they claimed not to keep — in 2017, for example, PureVPN handed the FBI connection records in a cyberstalking case despite advertising a no-logs policy — so the industry has learned that the promise is only as good as the proof behind it. That is why the useful question is not “does it say no-logs?” but “has the no-logs claim been tested, and how?” There are four signals worth looking for.
How a no-logs claim gets verified
Independent audits
A provider can hire an outside security or accounting firm to inspect its servers, settings and internal policies and report whether they match the no-logs claim. The big names do this repeatedly: NordVPN has passed a series of independent no-logs assessments — by PwC and, more recently, Deloitte — reaching its sixth in 2025; Proton VPN has been audited every year since 2022 (by Securitum), with the review covering both its free and paid servers; and Surfshark has been verified by Deloitte in 2023 and again in 2025. Two caveats are worth remembering: an audit is a snapshot of a single point in time, not continuous monitoring, and the full reports are often only available to logged-in account holders.
RAM-only (diskless) servers
Some providers run their servers entirely from RAM — volatile memory that is wiped every time the machine reboots or loses power — rather than writing anything to a hard drive. The idea is that even if a server is seized or compromised, there is no stored data to recover. Providers describe their networks this way — ExpressVPN through its TrustedServer system and Surfshark across its 100% RAM-only network — though the detail is the company’s own description and is rarely checked independently.
Court cases and server seizures
The strongest real-world test is what happens when authorities actually come looking. A few well-documented cases stand out:
- ExpressVPN, Turkey (2017): a server was seized as part of the investigation into the assassination of the Russian ambassador in Ankara. Investigators found no useful data on it, and ExpressVPN confirmed it held no connection logs for the addresses in question. It later switched that location to a virtual server hosted elsewhere.
- Private Internet Access, United States (2016 and 2018): in 2016 Private Internet Access answered an FBI subpoena in a case filed in a Florida court and could supply only that the IP addresses in question came from somewhere on the US east coast (reported by TorrentFreak); in 2018 its general counsel testified at a federal trial in San Jose that the company keeps no activity logs, so it had no useful records to hand over.
- Mullvad, Sweden (2023): Swedish police arrived at Mullvad’s Gothenburg office with a search warrant seeking customer data, and left with nothing because the data simply did not exist. (The honest caveat: police left after Mullvad demonstrated how its service works and they consulted the prosecutor, so the episode supports the claim rather than independently proving it.)
These cases are powerful because they are not marketing — but most of the detail still comes from the providers’ own accounts, so treat them as strong corroboration rather than absolute proof.
No-logs claims put to the test
| Provider | What happened | When | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| ExpressVPN | Server seized in Turkey during a murder investigation | 2017 | Inspection found no useful data; the provider confirmed it held no connection logs |
| Private Internet Access | Answered an FBI subpoena (2016, Florida case); general counsel testified at a federal trial in San Jose (2018) | 2016 & 2018 | Could give only an approximate east-coast IP range in 2016; testified it keeps no activity logs in 2018 |
| Mullvad | Police attended its office with a search warrant | 2023 | Left with no customer data because none was stored |
| NordVPN | Independent no-logs assessments (PwC, then Deloitte) | 2018–2025 | Passed its sixth assessment; found in line with its no-logs policy |
| Proton VPN | Annual independent no-logs audits (Securitum) | Since 2022 | Confirmed no-logs across both free and paid servers |
| Surfshark | Independent no-logs audit by Deloitte | 2023 & 2025 | Verified the no-logs policy applied across its servers |
Jurisdiction and transparency reports
Where a company is legally based affects what a government could compel it to do, and whether local law forces it to retain data. Many providers also publish transparency or “warrant canary” reports listing the data requests they receive and what they handed over — which, for a genuine no-logs service, is usually nothing. A long transparency record plus a recent audit is a much stronger combination than either on its own.
What a no-logs VPN does not mean
A no-logs policy is about activity and connection records — it is not a promise of total invisibility. Keep these limits in mind:
- Some data is still collected. To run the service, providers typically keep an account email, billing information and aggregate figures such as total bandwidth or crash reports. Good providers keep these separate from any record of what you did.
- It is not complete anonymity. A VPN masks your IP and encrypts your traffic, but tracking cookies, browser fingerprinting and simply logging in to your accounts can still identify you.
- Payment can leave a trail. Paying by card links a subscription to your name; a few providers — Mullvad among them — accept cash or a random account number to avoid this.
Does the VPN’s home country matter for New Zealanders?
New Zealand is one of the five members of the “Five Eyes” intelligence-sharing alliance, alongside the United States, United Kingdom, Canada and Australia; the GCSB is the NZ agency involved. Wider arrangements known as the Nine Eyes and Fourteen Eyes add countries such as the Netherlands, France, Germany and Sweden. In theory, a provider based in one of these countries could be pressed to assist an allied government.
In practice, jurisdiction only matters if the provider actually stores something worth handing over. An audited no-logs service running diskless servers has little to give regardless of where its office sits — which is exactly why the proof signals above matter more than the flag on the building. Whatever its home country, a VPN does not exempt you from New Zealand law or replace the protections of the Privacy Act: it changes who can see your traffic, not whether the rules apply to you.
How to check a no-logs claim yourself
Before you subscribe, run through this short checklist:
- Read the actual privacy policy, not the landing page. Look specifically at what the provider says it does collect and how long it keeps it.
- Find a recent independent audit. Check who carried it out and the date — a report from several years ago says little about the service today.
- Look for RAM-only or diskless servers. It is not a guarantee, but it limits what any single seized server could reveal.
- Check for a transparency report or a real legal test. A documented case where no user data was produced is the gold standard.
- Weigh the jurisdiction against whether the provider stores anything in the first place.
- Be wary of a free VPN. Running a global server network is expensive; if you are not paying, your data can be the product. A few reputable providers offer a genuinely no-logs free tier, but read the policy first.
- Pair it with a VPN kill switch so that if the encrypted tunnel drops, your real IP is not exposed in the gap.
Disclaimer
Using a VPN is legal in New Zealand. A no-logs policy protects your privacy; it does not place you above the law, and it will not make copyright infringement or other illegal activity legal. A VPN is also not a substitute for strong account security, antivirus software and sensible online habits. Choose a provider on verifiable evidence rather than marketing, and read its current privacy policy before you subscribe.
Reference sources
- Mullvad — VPN was subject to a search warrant, customer data not compromised (2023)
- Mullvad — Numbered accounts and paying with cash
- TorrentFreak — VPN server seized in Turkey investigation (ExpressVPN)
- TorrentFreak — PIA no-logging claim tested in 2016 FBI case
- TorrentFreak — PIA no-logging claims tested in court (2018)
- TorrentFreak — PureVPN logs helped the FBI despite no-logs claim (2017)
- Tom’s Hardware — How NordVPN proves its zero-logs promise (sixth audit)
- Proton VPN — Independent no-logs audit results
- Surfshark — No-logs statement verified by Deloitte
- Surfshark — Upgraded to 100% RAM-only servers
- ExpressVPN — TrustedServer (RAM-only) technology
- Surfshark — The 5, 9 and 14 Eyes alliances explained
Frequently asked questions
Which VPNs have actually proven they keep no logs?
Providers whose no-logs claims have survived a real test include ExpressVPN (a server seizure in Turkey), Private Internet Access (US court cases) and Mullvad (a Swedish police visit), while NordVPN, Proton VPN and Surfshark have been checked repeatedly by independent audit firms. None of this guarantees future behaviour, because audits only capture a single point in time — but it is far stronger than a marketing claim alone.
Can the FBI or police track you through a no-logs VPN?
If the provider genuinely keeps no activity or connection logs, there is nothing to hand over — that is what the Private Internet Access and ExpressVPN cases showed. However, you can still be identified by other means: logging in to your accounts, payment details, tracking cookies, browser fingerprinting, or malware on your own device. A VPN hides your IP and traffic; it is not a cloak of total anonymity.
Do Surfshark and other big names really keep no logs?
Surfshark’s no-logs policy has been examined by Deloitte (in 2023 and 2025) and the company says its servers run from RAM. That is strong evidence, though the full report is only available to account holders and any audit reflects a single point in time. Treat any provider’s claim as “verified as far as the last audit,” not a permanent guarantee.
Is a free VPN really no-logs?
Be cautious. Running a global server network costs money, and some free VPNs fund it by logging and selling user data or injecting ads. A few reputable providers — Proton VPN among them — offer a genuinely no-logs free tier, but always read the privacy policy of any free VPN before you trust it with your traffic.




